Argument Fallacies Guide & Task Cards

Welcome to the Logical Fallacies Exploration Packet!

Step into the fascinating world of logical reasoning and critical thinking. Understanding logical fallacies is like putting on a special pair of glasses that reveal hidden flaws in arguments. These common reasoning errors appear everywhere — from everyday conversations to advertisements to academic debates. This resource equips students with the tools they need to spot these fallacies and build stronger, clearer arguments. 27 pages

What’s Inside

• Clear explanations of common logical fallacies (Ad Hominem, Straw Man, False Dilemma, Slippery Slope, and more)
• Engaging task cards with real-world scenarios for students to analyze
• Guided practice activities to help students identify and correct faulty reasoning
• Critical thinking prompts that push students beyond surface-level answers
• Answer keys and teacher notes for easy facilitation

Why It’s Perfect for Gifted Learners

• Encourages higher-level thinking and metacognition
• Builds strong argumentation and reasoning skills
• Challenges students to identify subtle flaws in logic
• Encourages independent and group analysis of authentic scenarios
• Promotes debate, discussion, and intellectual curiosity

How to Use It

• Introduce one fallacy at a time using the clear guide pages.
• Use the task cards in small groups, pairs, or as a whole-class activity.
• Encourage students to defend their reasoning and respectfully challenge others.
• Extend learning by asking students to create their own fallacy examples or find real-world advertisements, speeches, or media clips that illustrate them.
• Use the included answer key and teacher tips to guide discussions and deepen understanding.

✨ Empower your students to think critically, question assumptions, and strengthen their reasoning skills with the Argument Fallacies Guide & Task Cards!